Direct answer: A 90 day game plan for new hires reverse-engineers success. Ask what would need to be true 90 days out. Map skills, scripts, org chart, decision bands, check-in cadence. Extend to 180 days per position. The playbook prevents 3-week quits.
Filmed in Sacramento, California | GPS 38.5816, -121.4944
Why Most Owners Fail At The 90 Day Game Plan For New Hires
Hands down, one of the biggest opportunities most entrepreneurs, offer owners, and practitioners have comes down to how they onboard a new employee — the conversations they have and the procedures they have in place. You may spend a ton of time, energy, and effort trying to find the right person to come on board. And then you or your team fails that person when it comes to their start. That gap between hiring and onboarding is where most talent quits within the first 90 days.
The solution is a documented 90 day game plan for every position. This concept sits inside the Exit Ratio 360™ system as one of the operational preparation topics that pairs directly with the hiring process framework. See how to build out a hiring process for the right candidate for the front-end companion — hiring correctly is only half the work; onboarding correctly is the other half.
The Reverse-Engineering Question That Starts Every 90 Day Game Plan
Here is the specific question that anchors the entire 90 day game plan design. Start with the position you are trying to fill today, then ask:
“What would need to be true 90 days out for this person to have success as we hire them?”
This is reverse-engineering. Instead of building onboarding forward from day one and hoping it produces a good employee at day 90, you start with what success looks like at day 90 and work backwards to design the specific interventions that produce that outcome.
The question forces clarity about what success actually means for the role — which is more difficult than most owners realize. Many roles have no defined day-90 success criteria at all, which is why the onboarding for those roles is inherently vague. Answering this one question first is what makes everything else in the 90 day game plan actually work.
The Nine Questions Your 90 Day Game Plan Must Answer
Once you have the day-90 success target, the 90 day game plan requires answering nine specific questions:
- Skills: What technical skills does this person need to demonstrate by day 90?
- Talents: What natural talents should this role reward?
- Capabilities: What operational capabilities must they build during the 90 days?
- Scripts: What specific communication scripts do they need for client, team, or vendor interactions?
- Org chart: Where do they sit in the organization structure?
- Decision bands: What can they decide independently, what needs escalation, and to whom?
- Support routing: Who do they go to when they need help with specific issues?
- Learning modalities: Do we need to role play? Have conversations? Show them what to do?
- Check-in cadence: How often do we check in and what format do those check-ins take?
Every position gets these nine answers documented before the first day. Positions that cannot be answered thoroughly are positions that will produce inconsistent new hire outcomes regardless of who you hire. See why the Foundational Four allows you to sell your business or take vacation for the org chart and decision bands framework the 90 day game plan builds on.
The Tools And Process For Building A 90 Day Game Plan
Here are the specific tools I recommend for building each position’s 90 day game plan:
- A whiteboard for high-level flow mapping
- 3×5 index cards for individual steps or milestones
- Sticky notes for sequencing and reorganizing
- Time blocked on the calendar to actually do the work
The physical tools matter because they force you to think in discrete units rather than paragraphs. Each index card represents one specific onboarding intervention. Each sticky note represents one specific milestone. Moving them around lets you sequence and re-sequence until the flow makes sense — which is nearly impossible to do in a Word document or Google doc where everything blends together.
Once mapped, the physical version gets translated into a written playbook that becomes part of your Foundational Four documentation.
The 3-Time Rule For Perfecting Your 90 Day Game Plan
Here is the timing reality nobody tells you. The first time you build a 90 day game plan for a position, it may be painful. It may take longer than you expect. Two to four hours per position is normal for the first pass.
The compounding pattern:
| Iteration | What Happens | Time Investment |
|---|---|---|
| First pass | Painful, slow, discovering gaps as you write | 2-4 hours per position |
| Second pass | Easier and faster — you have a template to modify | 45-90 minutes per position |
| Third pass and beyond | Easier and faster still — pattern recognition kicks in | 20-30 minutes per position |
On average it takes about three iterations to get any given position’s 90 day game plan right. Not because the first version is bad — because you learn things as new hires actually go through the process that only become visible in practice. The living document evolves through real deployment.
The Playbook That Becomes Your Foundational Four
Once the 90 day game plan is mapped, you build a playbook that formalizes the process. That playbook becomes part of your Foundational Four infrastructure:
- Standard operating procedures (SOPs) for the role
- Job description with decision bands
- Org chart placement
- Accountability framework (which is the subtitle of SOPs)
This is a living document. It will change over time. You are not going to get it perfect the first time — on average it takes three iterations to get right. But here is what employees coming in actually appreciate: they enjoy knowing that you have this mapped out and that it is not pure chaos. A documented onboarding process is one of the most under-appreciated retention tools available to owners.
The $50M Company Communication Director Perspective
Here is where my perspective on this comes from. Before consulting, I was a communication director for a $50 million heating and air company. When anyone came in to get hired, I did the 90 day game plan mapping for every department:
- Technicians
- Salespeople
- Office staff
- Installers
- Plumbers
- New managers
- Anyone who had a conversation with a client
It was my role and responsibility to help map out the onboarding process with each manager. I was not the sole person doing this — sometimes it takes teams. But what we found was measurable: we retained employees better than companies without a documented onboarding process. That retention improvement compounds directly into exit valuation because buyers pay premium multiples for businesses with proven retention systems.
The Check-In Schedule Every 90 Day Game Plan Requires
Here is the specific check-in cadence built into every 90 day game plan I have deployed:
- First 72 hours: Manager pulls the new employee aside. Preferably within the first 3 days. Ask: “Do you like your role? Are you happy with everything?” Then just listen. The person is going to tell you things you probably do not want to hear — but you want to hear them sooner rather than later.
- End of week 1: Formal sit-down conversation. Take their feedback seriously.
- End of week 2: Another formal check-in. Compare notes to week 1 to see if concerns are being resolved.
- Office hours going forward: Establish a specific window — for example, “Wednesdays from 7 to 8 in the morning, if there is a problem, come see me.”
- End of week 4: One month review of the 90 day game plan itself — is the plan working?
- End of week 8: Two-thirds review — course correction if needed.
- End of week 12: Full 90-day review and transition to standard performance management.
The 72-hour check-in matters more than most managers realize. Your hope and your dream and your desire is that the next person you have this conversation with is not saying the same thing that you have already taken care of. But you can only take care of what you actually hear about — which requires asking early and listening without defending.
The Manager Avoidance Pattern That Kills 90 Day Game Plan Effectiveness
Here is what actually happens in most organizations. Most managers and most business owners run from these check-in problems. They hire a person. The person is around for 3 or 4 weeks and quits. They hire another. That person is around for 6 weeks and quits. Then the owner asks:
“Why is this happening to me?”
Because you are not listening to the truth. You are not listening to what the problems could be. You are hoping and praying. You are crossing your fingers, looking up at the sky, and saying — I am hoping and praying that things are going to get fixed. And the chances of that happening are very slim. It could happen. Sure. On a Wednesday on a full moon when you stub your toe getting out of bed. Otherwise, no.
The fix is deliberate: build the check-in cadence into the 90 day game plan, force yourself to actually conduct the check-ins, listen without defending, and act on the feedback within days rather than weeks. See how accountability can help you grow, scale, or exit for the related accountability framework this check-in discipline requires.
Expanding From The 90 Day Game Plan To 180 Days
The 90 day game plan is the bare minimum starting point. Once you have completed a solid 90 day game plan for one position, expand it in two directions:
Direction 1: Extend to 180 days per position. When the first 90 days are done, map out the next 90 days. When somebody has half a year of directions they can go and things they can do, it signals to them from the business gods (and to buyers who eventually evaluate your business at exit) that you have got everything right and you are on the right direction.
Direction 2: Replicate across all positions. Start with one position. Take it to the rest of the team. Say: “This is what we want to see with everybody else. We want to map out the first 90 days for every position.”
The end state: every position in your organization has a documented 90-day and 180-day playbook. That documentation becomes a permanent asset that appreciates in value as your business scales — and dramatically increases buyer confidence at exit because it demonstrates operational maturity most sellers cannot show.
The Fit-Detection Benefit Of A Well-Built 90 Day Game Plan
Here is a benefit most owners underestimate. When you have a well-built 90 day game plan, you find out faster when somebody is a bad fit.
At the $50 million heating and air company, part of my role and responsibility was to figure out if somebody was a good fit within the first day. Based on their interactions during onboarding and the questions they asked, I could identify red flags and superstars alike:
- Red flag pattern: “Your new plumber is going to be a problem. The way they answered these questions was not good.”
- Superstar pattern: “I really think you got a superstar here. You may want to come talk to them and see what better they held back in their interview. They actually got more skills. Now that they are hired, they are more relaxed and able to tell you more and have a different conversation with you.”
The fit-detection benefit compounds. Bad fits identified in week 1 cost you 1 week of wages. Bad fits identified at week 12 cost you 3 months of wages plus the ripple effect on your team. Good fits identified early get accelerated development. See the three types of employees you will find when doing deals for the related framework on classifying team members.
If you are looking to sell your business in the next zero to thirty-six months, doing at least $2 million a year in revenue with a ten percent profit margin, the deal hotline is 888-DEAL-919. One of the team members will get back to you. No deal is too big.
Related cluster reading: how to build out a hiring process for the right candidate, should you hire top talent when you find it in the marketplace, how accountability can help you grow, scale, or exit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do you need a 90 day game plan for new hires?
Because most new hires quit within the first 90 days when there is no documented onboarding process. You spend enormous energy finding the right person, then you or your team fails them at the start by dropping them into pure chaos rather than a structured 90-day path. The 90 day game plan closes that gap and dramatically improves retention, which compounds directly into exit valuation.
What is the reverse-engineering question that starts the 90 day game plan?
“What would need to be true 90 days out for this person to have success as we hire them?” Instead of building onboarding forward from day one and hoping it produces a good employee at day 90, you start with what success looks like at day 90 and work backwards to design the specific interventions. This forces clarity about what success actually means for the role.
What tools do you use to build a 90 day game plan?
A whiteboard for high-level flow mapping, 3×5 index cards for individual steps, sticky notes for sequencing and reorganizing, and time blocked on your calendar to actually do the work. Physical tools force you to think in discrete units rather than paragraphs. Each index card represents one specific onboarding intervention. Moving them around lets you sequence and re-sequence until the flow makes sense.
What is the 3-time rule for building the 90 day game plan?
First pass: 2-4 hours per position. Painful, slow, discovering gaps as you write. Second pass: 45-90 minutes per position. Easier — you have a template. Third pass and beyond: 20-30 minutes per position. Pattern recognition kicks in. On average it takes about three iterations to get any given position’s 90 day game plan right because you learn things as new hires actually go through it.
How does the Foundational Four connect to the 90 day game plan?
The 90 day game plan becomes part of your Foundational Four documentation — standard operating procedures (SOPs) for the role, job description with decision bands, org chart placement, and accountability framework (which is the subtitle of SOPs). The playbook is a living document that will change over time, but each iteration strengthens the foundational infrastructure buyers evaluate at exit.
What check-in schedule should the 90 day game plan include?
First 72 hours: manager pulls new employee aside and just listens. End of week 1: formal sit-down. End of week 2: another formal check-in. Office hours going forward (example: “Wednesdays 7-8 AM if there is a problem, come see me”). End of week 4: one-month review. End of week 8: two-thirds review. End of week 12: full 90-day review and transition to standard performance management.
What is the “manager avoidance” pattern that kills new hires?
Most managers and business owners run from check-in problems. They hire a person who quits at 3-4 weeks. Hire another who quits at 6 weeks. Then ask “why is this happening to me?” Because they are not listening to the truth. They are hoping and praying, crossing fingers, looking up at the sky. The fix is deliberate: build check-ins into the plan, actually conduct them, listen without defending, act on feedback within days.
Should the 90 day game plan extend to 180 days?
Yes — after you have completed a solid 90 day game plan, extend to 180 days per position. When the first 90 days are done, map out the next 90. When somebody has half a year of directions they can go, it signals to them (and to buyers who eventually evaluate the business at exit) that operational infrastructure is real. The 180-day extension compounds retention and exit valuation.
How does a 90 day game plan help detect bad fits faster?
Well-built 90 day game plans surface bad fits within the first day based on interactions and question patterns. Bad fits identified in week 1 cost you 1 week of wages. Bad fits identified at week 12 cost you 3 months of wages plus the ripple effect on your team. Good fits identified early get accelerated development. The fit-detection benefit compounds significantly with a documented onboarding process.
Should every position have a 90 day game plan?
Yes — every position. Technicians, salespeople, office staff, installers, plumbers, new managers, anyone who has a conversation with a client. Start with one position, then take it to the rest of the team. The end state is every position in your organization having a documented 90-day and 180-day playbook. This becomes a permanent asset that appreciates in value as your business scales and dramatically increases buyer confidence at exit.
Full Transcript
Hands down, one of the biggest opportunities most entrepreneurs, offer owners, and practitioners have comes down to how they onboard a new employee — the conversations they have and the procedures they have in place. What does this have to do with your success and how you can grow a better business? This is a fantastic question. I am Scott Sylvan Bell coming to you live from Sacramento on a perfect day to talk about 90-day business plans, growth plans, hiring the right people, and a fantastic day to talk about you.
You may spend a ton of time, energy, and effort trying to find the right person to come on board — and it may be that you and your team is failing that person when it comes to their start. One of the best things for you to do is put together a 90-day onboarding process. Start with the position you are trying to fill today. Take a look and ask: what would need to be true 90 days out for this person to have success as we hire them?
Take a look and ask what skills, talents, and capabilities they need to have. What scripts do they need to have in place? What is the org chart? What are the decision bands? Who do they go to when they need help? Do we need to role play? Do we need to have conversations? Do we need to show them what to do? How often do we check in? Grab a whiteboard, 3×5 index cards, sticky notes — map this process out.
The first time you do it may be painful. It may take longer than you expect. What you are going to find is the next time it is easier and faster. And the next time after that it is easier and faster. Based on the role and responsibility inside the company, each one of these is probably going to take about 20 or 30 minutes once you have iterated on it a few times.
Build a playbook. Create your Foundational Four — standard operating procedures, job description with decision bands, and org charts. Fill this information out. Say: I am going to give my new employee the best 90-day intro they can have. This is a living document, which means it is going to change over time. You are not going to get it perfect the first time. On average, it takes about three times to get this right.
For the employee coming in, they actually enjoy knowing that you have this mapped out and it is not pure chaos. My name is Scott. I was a communication director for a company. When anybody came in to get hired, this is what I did for every department. It was a $50 million company that I worked at, a heating and air company. I did it for the technicians, salespeople, office staff, installers, anybody who had a conversation with a client. It was my role and responsibility to help map out the process with their manager. I was not the sole person, so sometimes it takes teams. But what we found was we retained employees better.
We also put in check-in dates. Within the first week, the manager pulled the new employee aside — preferably in the first 72 hours. Said: “Do you like your role? Are you happy with everything?” Then you just listen. Because that person is going to tell you things you probably do not want to hear. But you want to hear those sooner. Because the next person you have a conversation with, your hope and your dream and your desire is they are not saying the same thing that you have taken care of that problem. You take the feedback seriously. Then at the end of week 1 you bring them in. End of week 2 you bring them in. If need be, you say: listen, Wednesdays 7 to 8 in the morning, if there is a problem, come see me. I want to have this conversation.
Most managers, most business owners run from these problems. They go and hire a person. The person is around for 3 or 4 weeks and quits. They go through the whole process and hire another person. That person is around for 6 weeks and quits. They ask — why is this happening to me? Because you are not listening to the truth. You are not listening to what the problems could be. You are hoping and praying. You are crossing your fingers, looking up at the sky and saying — I am hoping and praying that things are going to get fixed. The chances of that happening are very slim. Can it? Yeah, I am sure it could. On a Wednesday on a full moon when you stub your toe getting out of bed.
Create this process and map it out. When it is done, go back and say: hey, did we do this right? You could be doing this as a weekly check-in. Did we as a team do this right?
Start with one position and then take it to the rest of the team. Say: this is what we want to see with everybody else. We want to map out the first 90 days. When the first 90 days are done, guess what? You are going to go map out the next 90. So you have 180 days for every position.
If somebody has half a year of directions they can go and things they can do, it is a sign from the business gods — looking up at the sky — that you have got everything right and you are on the right direction. You are going to find that as a benefit, when somebody is a bad fit, you are going to find out faster.
When I was the communications director for a company, part of my role and responsibility was to figure out if somebody was a good fit within the first day. Based on interactions, based on questions, we were able to have conversations with the management team. Every position had the same onboarding process. Plumbers, installers, technicians, salespeople, office staff, even the managers. New managers had to go through it. I would interact with them, and based on their interactions, I could point out red flags. I would call the manager and say: your new plumber is going to be a problem. The way they answered these questions was not good. Or: I really think you got a superstar here. You may want to come talk to them and see what better they held back in their interview. They actually got more skills. Now that they are hired, they are more relaxed and able to tell you more and have a different conversation with you. A 90-day onboarding process should be your bare minimum, starting with the newest position you are trying to hire for.
