Direct answer: An earn out is a conditional payment structure where you receive additional money if the business hits specific targets after sale. Some earn outs are genuine upside opportunities. Some are ego-based bait designed to extract free work from motivated sellers.
Filmed in Sacramento, California | GPS 38.5816, -121.4944
What An Earn Out Actually Is
If you are going to sell your business, one of the terms you will hear in the purchase agreement is an earn out. An earn out is a condition — a subject to clause when it comes to selling your business. The buyer says — we will pay you X dollars now and Y dollars more if you hit specific targets over some defined period after sale.
For the mechanical definition of earn outs and how they show up in the LOI, see what is an earn out in an LOI contract. This post is different. This one is about whether you should accept one. That is a completely separate question, and it deserves a completely separate answer.
The Math Example — $7 Million Vs $10 Million
Use easy numbers. Say you have $2.5 million in profit and you are getting a 2x multiple. That is a $7 million sale on paper. Totally unrealistic multiple, but this is for the example.
The buyer comes to you and says — hey, you think you have such a great business, we will give you $10 million if you can jump through these hoops for sales, renewals, and cancellations. If you can do those things, we will give you $10 million.
Your brain immediately does the math. Wait a minute. I have a seven figure deal if I sell for $7 million. But if I sell for $10 million, I have an eight figure deal. I have bragging rights. That psychology is exactly what earn outs are designed to trigger.
Three Seller Positions That Determine The Right Answer
The right answer on an earn out depends heavily on which of three positions you are actually in as the seller:
- The “I will work for it” position — I am at the age where I am willing to go into the office a couple days a week to make this work for an extra $3 million, or whatever the earn out number is.
- The “I don’t care anymore” position — I want out of my business. The extra money is not worth the extra time or emotional commitment.
- The “beach lifestyle” position — I want to live on the beach and never have to worry about a thing. Additional money tied to ongoing performance is the opposite of what I want.
Which position you are in is the first question to answer honestly. The wrong earn out decision for your actual position produces regret regardless of financial outcome.
The Preparation Question — Did You Actually Build For This?
The second question is whether you prepared your business for the earn out period. If you started preparing five, four, three, or two years out — and you have a management team in place — and they know what is supposed to happen — and there is a condition inside the agreement that the buying company or private equity firm cannot make major changes during the earn out period — then the earn out may work.
Without that preparation, the earn out targets become unreachable. The buyer’s changes to the business erode the metrics the earn out was measured on. You do the work. You do not get the money.
This connects to exit strategy planning for selling a business — the 24 to 36 month preparation runway is what makes earn outs viable in the first place. Without it, you are betting on outcomes you no longer control.
If you are looking to sell your business in the next zero to thirty-six months, doing at least $2 million a year in revenue with a ten percent profit margin, the deal hotline is 888-DEAL-919. One of the team members will get back to you. No deal is too big.
The Benjamin Franklin Framework — Two Columns Side By Side
You have two offers on the whiteboard. Grab a marker and Benjamin Franklin this. Two columns.
| $10 Million With Earn Out | $7 Million Free And Clear |
|---|---|
| Bragging rights — you did an eight figure deal | Cash in hand |
| More money if you hit the targets | One time offer |
| Maybe the beach house | Free and clear |
| The satisfaction of achieving a goal | No conditions, no ongoing commitment |
Neither column is right for everyone. The exercise forces you to see what you are actually trading for what.
The Emotional Toll — Two Types Of Founders
I have seen founders and owners during earn out periods — sometimes a year, sometimes two years — go two completely different directions. Recognizing which type you are is critical before you sign anything.
| Founder Type | What Happens During The Earn Out |
|---|---|
| Freaks out under pressure | Emotional breakdowns. Constant worry about hitting the magic number. Cannot separate personal identity from the business metric. The earn out consumes them. |
| Thrives on the challenge | Treats it like a puzzle. “I can do this.” The pressure sharpens performance. The earn out becomes a game they enjoy playing. |
The answer you choose is not necessarily the answer someone else would choose. But you need to think through — how do I react under pressure? A founder who freaks out should not sign an earn out for eight figures of psychological suffering. A founder who thrives on the puzzle probably should.
The Fall-Short Scenario — What If You Do Not Hit $10 Million?
Here is the question most sellers do not ask themselves. Right now, today, you can get $7 million free and clear. You go down the earn out path aiming for $10 million. What happens if you do not reach $10 million? You only hit $8.5 million. You only hit $9 million.
Are you going to be okay with that?
If yes — maybe the earn out is the right decision. You still made more than the free-and-clear alternative. If it is going to bother you for the rest of your life that you did not hit the full number — the earn out may not be the right way for you to go.
It is not just the money. It is the emotional toll it may take on you. It is not just the money. It may be the bragging rights you were hoping to achieve in front of friends and family members.
The Oscillation — Nobody Ever Tells You About This Part
Here is the thing that nobody ever tells you about earn out decisions. This is a personal decision, and it is hard. You will oscillate.
You may think — I made the right decision. Then your brain tells you — but you could have had $3 million more, or whatever the number is. Or you decide to go for the earn out, and then you think — I could be sitting on the beach right now. You have both sides of this oscillation running in your head.
Before you sign, I would encourage you — if you are looking at a contract and you have an earn out provision where one side offers more than the other — do not just make a fast decision. Maybe talk to a therapist. Maybe talk to a trusted advisor. For how to evaluate a trusted advisor, see before you hire an advisor or consultant, understand this one rule.
Ask directly — what are the pros and cons, and am I okay if I do not reach this number? The numbers I used ($7M and $10M) are arbitrary examples. Whatever numbers are in front of you, know this — it is not going to be easy. They are putting a goal in front of you. Unless your team is prepared for it, hitting the target will not be easy.
The Bait — How A Few Bad Actors Use Earn Outs Against You
This does not apply to everybody. There are just a few individuals in the world who play this game. But you need to know it exists so you can recognize it.
They come to you and say — “Mr. Founder, Mr. Owner, if your company is so good, it is proof to us that you have a good company if you do this. It is proof to us.”
The subject to clause underneath says — if you do not achieve these things, you are not getting the money. Sometimes there is a penalty clause on top. Sometimes these companies know you will never hit those numbers. It is statistically impossible. They are able to get extra work out of you because of your ego.
The bait script sounds like this:
- “If your company is so good, you should accept this.”
- “It’s proof. It’s proof.”
- “A really strong founder wouldn’t hesitate to take this.”
When somebody does this to me, it is proof to me that they are probably not a person I want to do business with. If you have acquisition criteria or selling criteria that says — under these circumstances I am willing to sell — one of those criteria should be that if somebody tries to bait you, your response is: peace out, deuces. I am not going to do that.
When you are looking at an earn out, you are already under emotional duress because you are selling your business. Be aware that a few people use this against you. When they come at you at that angle, now you know. Now you can say — I see the game you are playing.
The Forced Earn Out — When You Do Not Have A Choice
Sometimes earn outs are not optional. Sometimes it is — as a condition of us buying the company, you are going to have to accept an earn out. If you do not have all the operational elements in place — the framework the Exit Ratio 360™ book walks through — you may not be able to negotiate it away. You may have to accept the earn out or walk from the deal entirely.
Preparation is the antidote to forced earn outs. The more professionalized your business is before you sell — with management, SOPs, clean books, and documented processes — the less leverage the buyer has to force you into a conditional payment structure.
Related cluster reading: what is a subject to clause in an LOI contract, what are payment terms in an LOI, what is a purchase price in an LOI, what is a reps and warranty clause in an LOI.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an earn out when selling a business?
An earn out is a subject to clause in a purchase agreement that ties additional payment to specific targets after sale. The buyer pays a base amount at closing and additional money over a defined period only if the business hits agreed sales, renewal, or performance metrics. Missing the targets means missing the extra money.
How much can an earn out add to your total sale price?
The earn out can add significant money on paper. Example: $2.5 million profit at a 2x multiple gives you a $7 million base sale. The buyer may offer $10 million total with the difference tied to hitting sales, renewal, and cancellation targets. The extra $3 million is real only if you actually hit the targets.
When should you accept an earn out?
Accept an earn out when three things are true: you are willing to stay involved for the earn out period, your business is prepared with management and SOPs so the targets are actually hittable, and the contract prevents the buyer from making major changes that erode the metrics. Without all three, the earn out likely fails.
When should you decline an earn out?
Decline an earn out when you want out of the business, when you want the beach lifestyle with no ongoing commitment, or when you know you would freak out under the pressure of hitting monthly targets. The free-and-clear lower amount is often the better choice for founders whose priority is clean separation.
What is the emotional toll of an earn out?
The emotional toll varies by founder type. Some founders freak out during earn out periods, have emotional breakdowns, and cannot separate personal identity from hitting the number. Others thrive on the challenge, treat it like a puzzle, and enjoy the pressure. Knowing which type you are is critical before signing.
What if you fall short of your earn out target?
Ask yourself directly — if I take $7 million free and clear versus aiming for $10 million and only hit $8.5 million, am I okay with that? If yes, the earn out may be worth it. If falling short will bother you for the rest of your life, the free-and-clear lower amount is the right decision regardless of the math.
How do buyers use earn outs against sellers?
A small number of buyers set earn out targets they know are statistically impossible to hit. They combine unreachable targets with penalty clauses and use the seller’s ego to extract additional work during the earn out period without ever paying the promised additional money. Recognizing the pattern is the only defense.
What is the “if your company is so good” bait?
The bait is a script bad-actor buyers use to leverage founder ego. It sounds like — “if your company is so good, you should accept this, it’s proof.” The implied challenge is that a strong founder would take the deal without hesitation. The correct response when you recognize the pattern is to decline and walk.
Is an earn out ever forced by the buyer?
Yes. Sometimes the earn out is non-negotiable — the buyer says accepting the earn out structure is a condition of them buying the company at all. Sellers without a professionalized business, clean books, and strong operational structure have less leverage to negotiate the earn out away. Preparation reduces forced earn outs.
Should you consult professionals about an earn out decision?
Yes. Talk to a therapist about the emotional dimension. Talk to a trusted advisor about the financial and strategic dimension. Ask the direct question — am I okay if I do not reach this number? Do not make a fast decision. The earn out is not just about the money. It is about the emotional toll and the ongoing commitment.
Full Transcript
If you are going to sell your business, one of the terms that you are going to hear for the purchase agreement is going to be an earn out. You may say — hey Scott, what is an earn out, and how do I know if I need one, and how do I protect myself? This is a fantastic question. I am Scott Sylvan Bell, coming to you live from Consulting Secrets on a perfect day to talk about business, selling businesses, earn outs, and a fantastic day to talk about you.
An earn out is a condition. It is a subject to clause when it comes to you selling your business. Use really easy numbers. Say that you have a $2.5 million profit and you are getting a 2x multiple. That is going to give you a $7 million sale. Totally unrealistic, but this is just for the example.
The buyer comes to you and says — hey, you think you have such a great business. We will give you $10 million if you can jump through these hoops for sales, renewals, cancellations. If you can do those things, we will give you $10 million. Your brain goes — hey, wait a minute. I have a seven figure deal if I sell for $7 million, but if I sell for $10 million, I have an eight figure deal, and I have bragging rights.
You have to know that sometimes when it comes down to it, earn outs are used against you. Earn outs are one of those things where it is like — if we stretch, we can probably make this work.
You may say — hey listen, I am at the age where I am willing to go into the office a couple days a week to try to make this work for an extra $3 million, or whatever number it happens to be for your earn out. Or you might say — you know what, I do not care anymore, I want out of my business.
When you are sitting there thinking — do I take an earn out or not — part of this conversation is going to come down to: do you really want out of the business? Part of this conversation is going to be: did you prepare your business in a way that you are going to get that earn out? If you started preparing five, four, three, two years out, and you have a management team in place, and they know what is supposed to happen, and there is a condition inside your agreement that the company buying you or the private equity firm buying you does not make any major changes during the time period of that earn out so it does not adjust and cause complications, then it may be the right thing for you.
But if you are like — I want to go live on the beach and have the beach lifestyle and never have to worry about a thing — these are all areas you need to take into account.
We have two offers here. I have my whiteboard. We have a $10 million offer, but you are going to have to reach sales goals, you are going to have to get renewals, you are going to have to not worry about cancellations. Depending upon the industry and the product you serve, you are going to have to take a look at what those buckets are. Or free and clear cash.
I cannot tell you what to do. I cannot tell you here is the excellent direction you are going to take. But if you are going to Benjamin Franklin this idea and build out two columns and say — what are the pros and cons of me sticking around for an earn out if I can get more? At the top, put bragging rights. I did an eight figure deal. Put more money, maybe a beach house, the fact that I was able to achieve a goal. On the other side at $7 million, put cash, one time offer, free and clear.
I have seen founders — for whatever time period, a year or two during this earn out period — freak out, have emotional breakdowns because they are so worried about hitting this magic number that they do not do well emotionally. On the other hand, I have seen founders and owners thrive on this. It is a puzzle. It is a thing. I can do this.
The answer you are going to choose is not necessarily my answer, but I want you to really think through — how do I react under pressure? Say for a second, today, right now, you can get $7 million free and clear. You go down the path of saying — well, I will do an earn out and I will go for $10 million. What happens if you do not reach that $10 million and you only hit $8.5 million? You only hit $9 million. Are you going to be okay with that? If yes, maybe a good decision. But if it is going to bother you for the rest of your life, it may not be the right way for you to go.
It is not just the money. It is the emotional toll that it may take on you. It is not just the money. It may be the bragging rights that you are hoping to achieve in front of friends and family members.
Here is the thing that nobody ever tells you. This is a personal decision, and it is hard. You may oscillate. You may think — I made the right decision, and then your brain tells you — but you could have had $3 million more. Or you might decide to go for this earn out and think — I could be sitting on the beach right now. You have both sides of this oscillation.
I would encourage you — if you are looking at a contract and you have an earn out provision where one side offers more than the other — to not just make a fast decision. Maybe talk to a therapist. Maybe talk to a trusted advisor and say — what are the pros and cons, and am I okay if I do not reach this number? The seven and the ten are arbitrary. I made those numbers up for this example. But whatever numbers happen to be in front of you, you need to know that it is not going to be easy. They are putting a goal in front of you. If someone is like — I am going to give you $3 million — it is probably not going to be easy unless your team is prepared for it.
I want to give you one example where you can be baited. This is not everybody. This is a few individuals in the world. You do need to know you can be baited for this. This is what it comes down to. They will come to you and say — hey Mr. Founder, Mr. Owner, if your company is so good, it is proof to us that you have a good company if you do this. It is proof to us. Well, you have a subject to clause where it is like — if you do not achieve these things, you are not getting the money. Sometimes there is a penalty clause. Sometimes these companies know that you will never hit those numbers. It is statistically impossible. They are able to get extra work out of you because of your ego.
They come to you and say — Mr. Mrs. Owner, if your company is so good, you should accept this. It is proof. It is proof. When somebody does that, to me it is proof that they are probably not a person that I always want to do business with. If you have acquisition criteria or selling criteria that says under these circumstances I am willing to sell — if one of them is where somebody tries to bait you — your response is: peace out, deuces. I am not going to do that.
That may work to your favor. When you are taking a look at an earn out, you are already under emotional duress because you are selling your business. Be aware that there are a few, not everybody, a few people who use this against you. When they come at you at that angle, now you know. Now you are like — oh, I see the game you are playing. I know what is up.
Should you accept an earn out provision in your agreement? Sometimes it is forced. Sometimes it is like — as a condition of us buying the company, you are going to have to accept an earn out. If you do not have all the things in place, like the Exit Ratio 360™ system goes through in the book, then what is going to happen is you may have to accept it. Under the conditions of this contract, you have to do an earn out. In the first example I gave you, you could do an earn out. It is your choice.
